Advance, loan, garnishment: the differences
A pay advance (acompte in France) is early payment for work already done; a cash advance or a loan pays money for work not yet done; a garnishment takes part of the salary to pay one of the employee’s creditors. Each has its own limits.
| Deduction | What it is | Deduction limit |
|---|---|---|
| Pay advance | Part of the month’s salary, paid before payday for work already done | Deducted in full from that month’s payroll |
| Cash advance | Money paid for work not yet done | France: one tenth of the salary per month. Switzerland: the seizable part of the salary |
| Loan | Money lent by the employer, with a repayment schedule | The seizable part of the salary, in both countries |
| Garnishment | A deduction ordered in favour of the employee’s creditor | France: statutory scale. Switzerland: whatever exceeds the subsistence minimum |
Advances and loans in France
- Pay advance (acompte). A monthly-paid employee who asks for one is entitled to an advance equal, for a fortnight, to half of the monthly salary (article L3242-1 of the Labour Code). It is deducted from that month’s payroll.
- Cash advance. The employer does not have to grant one. A cash advance is repaid through successive deductions of no more than one tenth of the salary due (article L3251-3). This deduction comes on top of the seizable portion.
- Loan. The one-tenth limit only covers advances: a loan is repaid through deductions within the seizable portion of the salary. Put it in a written agreement setting the amount, the schedule and what happens if the employee leaves.
Advances and loans in Switzerland
- Advance. An employee in need can obtain advances, in proportion to work already performed and to what the employer can reasonably provide (article 323 para. 4 of the Code of Obligations).
- Deductions. The employer can only offset a claim against the employee, loan repayments included, against the seizable part of the salary. Only claims arising from damage caused intentionally escape that limit (article 323b para. 2 CO).
- Loan. As in France, a written agreement with the repayment schedule avoids disputes, especially when the employee leaves.
Wage garnishment in France
Since 1 July 2025, wage garnishment (saisie des rémunérations) no longer goes through a judge: it is handled by a commissaire de justice (enforcement officer) and recorded in a digital register. The employer, as “third-party garnishee”, has three obligations:
- Declare within 15 days of being served the garnishment order: the employment relationship, the amount of pay, and any assignments, garnishments or direct payments already in progress.
- Withhold and pay over every month the seizable portion to the distributing commissaire de justice.
- Report within 8 days any event that suspends or ends the garnishment, such as a departure or a suspension of the contract.
An employer who fails to declare, or declares falsely, faces a civil fine of up to €10,000 and damages. If it does not pay over the deductions, it can be ordered to pay them itself.
The calculation base is net pay: salary and its extras, bonuses and benefits in kind included, after mandatory social contributions and income tax withheld at source. Expense reimbursements and family allowances are excluded. An amount equal to the RSA (minimum income) for a single person, €651.69 a month since 1 April 2026, always remains with the employee.
Maintenance payments follow a separate rule: direct payment is taken first from the normally unseizable portion, but the RSA amount always remains with the employee.
Worked example in France (2026 scale)
The scale sets a seizable fraction for each band of annual pay (article R3252-2 of the Labour Code). Each threshold rises by €1,740 per dependant.
| Annual pay band (2026) | Seizable fraction |
|---|---|
| Up to €4,480 | 1/20 |
| €4,480 to €8,730 | 1/10 |
| €8,730 to €13,000 | 1/5 |
| €13,000 to €17,230 | 1/4 |
| €17,230 to €21,470 | 1/3 |
| €21,470 to €25,810 | 2/3 |
| Above €25,810 | All of it |
Worked case. An employee with no dependants earns €2,000 net a month, or €24,000 a year. Each fraction is applied to its band:
- €4,480 × 1/20 = €224
- €4,250 × 1/10 = €425
- €4,270 × 1/5 = €854
- €4,230 × 1/4 = €1,057.50
- €4,240 × 1/3 = €1,413.33
- €2,530 × 2/3 = €1,686.67
Total: €5,660.50 a year, i.e. €471.71 a month to withhold. The employee keeps €1,528.29, above the RSA amount. With one dependant, the thresholds rise by €1,740 and the deduction drops to €382.29 a month.
Wage garnishment in Switzerland
In Switzerland, the debt enforcement office sets the seizable portion: everything above the subsistence minimum of the debtor and their family (article 93 of the Debt Enforcement and Bankruptcy Act, LP/SchKG). That minimum starts from a base amount, CHF 1,200 a month for a single person under the guidelines of the debt enforcement offices, applied for example in Geneva and Fribourg, plus rent, health insurance and certain work-related costs.
- The garnishment notice. Once notified, the employer can only validly pay the seized portion to the office (article 99 LP). If it pays it to the employee, it risks paying twice.
- Duration. A wage garnishment lasts at most one year from when it is carried out.
- Changes. Tell the office if the salary changes or the contract ends.
Example. For a net salary of CHF 5,000, the office sets a subsistence minimum of CHF 3,100: CHF 1,200 base amount, CHF 1,400 rent, CHF 400 health insurance and CHF 100 transport costs. The employer pays CHF 1,900 a month to the office. These amounts are illustrative: only the office sets the subsistence minimum, case by case.
In payroll: the order of operations
- Calculate net pay: gross, contributions, then, in France, income tax withheld at source.
- Deduct the pay advance already paid during the month.
- Calculate the garnishment on the legal base and pay it to the commissaire de justice (France) or the debt enforcement office (Switzerland).
- Withhold advance and loan repayments within their respective limits.
- Show each deduction on a separate payslip line, so the employee can check it.
Advances and loans in Illizeo
In Illizeo, employees request a pay advance or a loan from their own space. The request follows your approval workflow, which can treat amounts above the contract’s monthly salary differently. Loans are capped based on the contract’s salary and the outstanding balance. Once granted, the advance and the loan instalments appear in the draft payroll and are deducted automatically.
Learn more: Preliminary payroll.
FAQ — Frequently asked questions
How much of a salary can be garnished in France in 2026?
It depends on the annual scale and the number of dependants: 1/20 on the first band, up to all of it above €25,810 a year. An amount equal to the RSA for a single person, €651.69 a month since April 2026, always remains with the employee.
Can an employer refuse a pay advance?
In France, not for a monthly-paid employee asking for an advance on work already done, up to half of the monthly salary. A cash advance, on the other hand, is not mandatory. In Switzerland, the employer grants an employee in need the advances it can reasonably provide, in proportion to work already performed.
What does an employer risk if it does not apply a garnishment?
In France, it can be ordered to pay the amounts not withheld itself, and a missing or false declaration exposes it to a civil fine of up to €10,000. In Switzerland, if it pays the seized portion to the employee, it is not discharged and risks paying twice.
Can a bonus or a 13th-month salary be garnished?
Yes. In France, the base includes salary and its extras, bonuses included; only expense reimbursements and family allowances are excluded. In Switzerland, the debt enforcement office takes all employment income into account.
How long does a wage garnishment last?
In Switzerland, one year at most for a given garnishment. In France, it continues until the debt is paid or the garnishment is lifted.
Employee request, approval workflow, calculated cap and automatic deduction in the draft payroll.

