Time tracking and time clocks: what the law requires in Switzerland and France
BLOG

Time tracking and time clocks: what the law requires in Switzerland and France

Should your employees clock in and out? In Switzerland, recording working time is the rule; in France, it depends on how working hours are organised. Here is what the law requires in both countries, what it forbids, and how to choose a time clock.

Wilfrid Paul Robert Dusseaux21 November 20266 min de lecture

Is time tracking mandatory?

In Switzerland, yes: employers must record their employees’ working time, with regulated exceptions. In France, employers must count each employee’s hours as soon as not everyone follows the same collective schedule. In both countries the law requires an outcome (knowing the time worked), not a tool: a time clock is just one way to get there.

Switzerland: what OLT 1 requires

Article 73 of Ordinance 1 to the Labour Act (OLT 1) requires employers to keep available to the authorities the records needed to check compliance with the law. These records show in particular the daily and weekly working time actually worked, compensatory work and overtime included, with start and end times, as well as breaks of half an hour or more. They must be kept for at least five years.

  • Waiving time recording (article 73a OLT 1). Only possible if a collective labour agreement provides for it, for employees with great autonomy who set their own hours in most cases, whose gross annual salary exceeds CHF 120,000 (bonuses included), and with their written consent, revocable every year.
  • Simplified recording (article 73b OLT 1). For employees who set a significant part of their own hours, only daily working time is recorded, plus the start and end of night or Sunday work. It requires an agreement with employee representatives or, failing that, with the majority of employees. In companies with fewer than 50 employees, an individual written agreement is enough, together with an annual discussion on workload.
  • Inspections. Cantonal labour inspectorates check these records.

These rules apply to companies covered by the Labour Act. Some sectors and roles are excluded: check your situation before concluding that no recording is required.

France: counting working time

When the employees of a department or team do not all follow the same posted collective schedule, the employer must count each person’s working time: every day, by recording start and end times or the number of hours worked, and every week, by totalling the hours (articles L3171-2 and D3171-8 of the Labour Code).

  • Employees on a days-based contract (forfait jours). Their hours are not counted, but their days worked are. The employer must also monitor their workload and ensure rest periods are respected.
  • Retention. Time-counting records are kept for one year (article D3171-16), three years for employees on a forfait jours. In practice, keep this data for at least three years: that is how long an employee can claim unpaid wages, overtime included (article L3245-1 of the Labour Code).
  • EU law. In 2019, the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled that member states must require employers to set up an objective, reliable and accessible system for measuring daily working time (case C-55/18). France has not made it a general obligation, but the Cour de cassation refers to it in overtime disputes.

Badge, app, biometrics: what is allowed

Badges, PIN codes, QR codes or mobile apps raise no particular difficulty, as long as employees are informed. Biometrics (fingerprint, face, palm) is another matter:

  • France. The CNIL, France’s data protection authority, considers biometrics excessive for checking working hours: its model regulation only allows it for access to premises, tools or applications that justify it. Access-control logs must not be used to check working hours either.
  • Switzerland. Biometric data that uniquely identifies a person is sensitive data under the nFADP. Its use must be proportionate and transparent; offering an alternative (badge, code) is recommended, and the system must not be used to monitor employee behaviour (article 26 OLT 3).
  • Geolocation. Clocking in from a geolocated app must remain proportionate: the location is only useful at the moment of clocking, not continuously.

Inform and consult before rolling out

In France, no information about an employee can be collected through a system that has not been brought to their attention beforehand (article L1222-4 of the Labour Code). In companies with 50 or more employees, the CSE must also be informed and consulted before any means of monitoring activity is introduced (article L2312-38). In Switzerland, inform employees before go-live too: what is recorded, who can see it, how long it is kept. Company rules or a written notice set these points down.

What the system should check

Time tracking is only useful if it lets you check the rules. A good system flags on its own:

  • unjustified days and missing clock-ins;
  • maximum working time exceeded: 45 or 50 hours a week in Switzerland depending on the sector (article 9 of the Labour Act), 10 hours a day and 48 hours a week in France;
  • insufficient daily rest: 11 consecutive hours in both countries (article 15a of the Labour Act, article L3131-1 of the French Labour Code);
  • missing breaks;
  • overtime, night, Sunday and public-holiday work to be paid at a premium or compensated;
  • conflicts between a clock-in and a booked absence.

Choosing a time clock

The right terminal depends on your flows, your hygiene constraints and what you are allowed to collect. Look at:

  • clocking methods: badge, QR code, and biometrics only where justified;
  • connectivity: wired network or Wi-Fi, and local storage in case of an outage;
  • integration: clock-ins should reach your HRIS without manual export;
  • usability: a readable screen, interface languages, a balance visible to the employee;
  • multi-site: several terminals, one configuration.

Time tracking in Illizeo

Illizeo connects time tracking to the rest of time management:

  • clocking via ZKTeco Ultima time clocks (RFID or NFC badge, QR code, biometrics where you are allowed to use it), from the app or by manual entry;
  • each day rebuilt from the employee’s attendance profile and schedule;
  • eleven alerts raised automatically: unjustified day, daily limit exceeded, insufficient rest, missing break, conflict with an absence…;
  • counters for overtime, night, Sunday and public-holiday hours, to be paid or converted into time off after approval;
  • export to payroll, with a preview.

Learn more: Attendance & badging.

FAQ — Frequently asked questions

Do managers have to record their time?

In Switzerland, yes, unless recording is waived (article 73a OLT 1) or simplified (article 73b) under the conditions set; employees in a senior executive position fall outside the Labour Act. In France, managers whose time is counted in hours are covered; for those on a forfait jours, days worked are counted, and senior executives are excluded from working-time rules.

Can a fingerprint time clock be imposed?

In France, not for checking working hours: the CNIL considers biometrics excessive for that purpose. In Switzerland it is not prohibited, but biometric data is sensitive data: its use must be proportionate and transparent, and a non-biometric alternative is recommended.

How long should time-tracking data be kept?

In Switzerland, at least five years (article 73 OLT 1). In France, one year for time-counting records (three years for forfaits jours); keeping them for three years is prudent, since an employee can claim unpaid hours for three years.

Is clocking in from a phone valid?

Yes, in both countries, if the system is reliable and employees are informed. Geolocation, if used, must be limited to the moment of clocking.

What does a company risk if it does not record working time?

In an overtime dispute, an employer who cannot produce time records is in a weak position against the evidence presented by the employee. In Switzerland, the labour inspectorate can also require the company to comply.

From badge to payslip, with no re-keying

Time clocks, attendance profiles, automatic alerts, counters and payroll export in Illizeo.

Explore Attendance & badging


À lire aussi

Les derniers articles du blog Illizeo.

Tous les articles →
HRIS RFP template: free download
BLOG

HRIS RFP template: free download

22 November 2026

Wage garnishment and salary advances: the calculation step by step
BLOG

Wage garnishment and salary advances: the calculation step by step

21 November 2026

Expense report app: how to choose
BLOG

Expense report app: how to choose

21 November 2026